Making Sense of the Breakfast Debate

3493333046_ee6f406674_b

Maybe you’ve been reading about the widely reported study that calls into question the value of breakfast for weight loss, including this article in the New York Times on the “myths” surrounding breakfast and weight.  This article in iVillage takes it even further — which I found particularly troubling:  “Put down the Wheaties! Breakfast doesn’t champion anything but a bigger waistline. That most important meal of the day is really just a heap of extra calories.”   Really?  That goes too far.

So many of the stories seem to suggest that we’ve all been hoodwinked into eating breakfast and it’s a myth that the morning meal makes any difference in our weight – even implying that we might be better off skipping breakfast if we want to lose weight.  The iVillage article makes it seem like breakfast is the culprit.


Hogwash.  That was the topic of my latest column for WebMD’s Real Life Nutrition blog.

This all stems from a new study in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition that was conducted by a research team at the University of Alabama at Birmingham.  They concluded that our belief in the “proposed effect of breakfast on obesity” goes beyond what scientific evidence supports.  We presume it to be true.  They even suggest that the studies indicating a weight loss benefit of eating breakfast were simply misconstrued – influenced by the bias of the researchers who conducted those studies.

The new study picks apart the scientific literature on breakfast and concludes that missing breakfast has either little or no effect on weight gain, or people who eat breakfast end up consuming more calories at the end of the day than those who skip it.  The Alabama researchers are even critical of the findings from the National Weight Control Registry that showed regularly eating breakfast was one of the habits of people who have lost a significant amount of weight and kept it off for at least a year.  They claim that this research is the basis of widespread misinformation.  Wow, that was a bold conclusion — I think we have a lot to learn from real life people who have found a way to manage their weight.  Real life scenarios can sometimes be more insightful than statistical spreadsheets. Maybe it’s not cause and effect, but it works for them.

With this new study, the researchers from Alabama set out to disprove the notion that “breakfast is the most important meal of the day.”   So they conducted a meta-analysis – or an investigation that looked at a collection of studies – to demonstrate that this is simply a belief, not a scientific truth.  I get that, but what’s the point?

Do we really need to have people question if they should eat breakfast?  Do we really want them to skip breakfast so they can “save” their calories for later in the day?  That’s not a good strategy — it will likely backfire.  And besides, bias or not, people who are successful at maintaining their weight do tend to eat breakfast.  It’s truly a healthy habit that we should encourage.

Perhaps the scientific evidence on breakfast and weight is mixed.  I don’t care.  There’s enough proof to me that breakfast can make a difference.  And there are many other reasons to eat a healthy morning meal besides the number on the scale.  Studies have consistently shown that breakfast impacts cognitive function – benefiting memory and performance, both at work and in the classroom.  It’s also mighty tough to make up for the nutrients missed at breakfast if you skip it.  There’s an unquestionable amount of research that backs this up.

Yes, maybe some researchers have a personal bias that spills over into studies.  That’s probably worth exploring.  But why pick on breakfast to try and prove this point?  I still believe breakfast is a smart weight loss strategy.  It’s a healthy habit that helps set the tone for the day.  It gets you off on the right foot, which can impact the rest of your day.

So I say go ahead and keep eating breakfast.  Just make it a good one – a little protein to keep you full, whole grains, fruit and low-fat dairy.  Breakfast is one of the 12 healthy habits in my book, and you’ll find lots of ways to start off your day (including some on-the-go breakfast ideas if you’re prone to skip).

Maybe breakfast is not THE  most important meal of the day, but it’s still important.

image courtesy of jonolist on flickr

 

Enjoy this?

share it

Discuss

4 Comments

  • blipton

    “Do we really need to have people question if they should eat breakfast? Do we really want them to skip breakfast so they can “save” their calories for later in the day? That’s not a good strategy — it will likely backfire. And besides, bias or not, people who are successful at maintaining their weight do tend to eat breakfast. It’s truly a healthy habit that we should encourage.”

    This type of thinking is what’s wrong with listening to doctors, nutritionists, without doing the proper research oneself.

    The facts should speak for themselves… not hidden or manipulated because doctor/govt/nutritionist “knows” best.

    The rationale is always.. if people were told that A,B,C is ok, then they might not stop there and do A,B, C, D, E, F! Hence, we (doctors, nutrition bodies, etc) need to report not the truth, but rather act as parents and report A,B,C is not ok.

    People should be given the facts, whatever they may be, and let adults choose what they will..

    DOWN WITH THE NANNY STATE!!

    • Not sure I’m following your logic. This is not a nanny state argument. I’m saying what you’re saying — do what’s best for you. Don’t jump on the bandwagon that breakfast is bad just because a new report says it won’t help you lose weight. The articles reporting on this study are making it appealing to skip breakfast — I just don’t want people to think this is a good option.

  • Alex

    Nice article. Thanks for sharing both sides. Don’t forget that veggies can have a home in the AM as well inside juices, smoothies or Mediterranean breakfasts

  • Guest

    Articles like those published on iVillage and in the NYTimes are ridiculous and misleading, especially for parents. Study after study has shown kids who eat breakfast perform better in school, are less distracted, and have more energy.than kids who don’t. I swear by breakfast and won’t let the mainstream media tell me what’s right for my family. Great article!!

Copyright 2018 Nutrition Unplugged
Disclosure
Design by cre8d