Is Sugar the New Tobacco?


We have made a giant leap away from fat phobia and have firmly made sugar public enemy #1.

Or that’s how it seems.

Last week the FDA elevated the sugar issue by proposing to list “added sugars” on nutrition labels for the first time — while dropping the “calories from fat” declaration.  

Now the World Health Organization has escalated sugar concerns even more today by proposing that daily sugar intake should be just 5 percent of your total calories — half of what the agency previously recommended.

After a review of about 9,000 studies, WHO’s expert panel says dropping sugar intake to 5 percent of calories (or about 6 teaspoons of sugar or 25 grams per day) will help combat obesity. That includes sugars added to foods (such as sucrose or table sugar) and those naturally present in honey, syrups,  fruit juices and fruit concentrates, but not those occurring naturally in fruits.

The American Heart Association recommends limiting sugar intake to no more than 100 calories per day for women (about 6 teaspoons) and no more than 150 calories per day for men (9 teaspoons). 

Studies show that people who consume many foods and drinks with added sugars tend to consume more calories than people who don’t eat much of these foods, according to the National Institutes of Health.

Cutting back could help you maintain a healthy weight, and reduce risk for diabetes, heart disease, and other obesity-related health problems. Americans eat a lot more sugar than that: Our average sugar intake would have to drop by two-thirds to meet WHO’s suggested limit.

One of the loudest voices against sugar has been Dr. Robert Lustig, who seemed to get the “sugar is toxic” ball rolling with this viral video.

In recent years, there’s been all sorts of efforts to restrict sugar — proposing regulations similar to tobacco and alcohol.  Some people claim sugar is addicting, just like cocaine and heroin.

To me, I feel like we’re always looking to nail a victim.  We have to blame something.  Sure, if you drink a lot of sugary beverages and eat a ton of sweets — you’ll likely be consuming too many calories.  But I have a hard time believing that sugar is “toxic.”

I do think calling out “added sugars” on nutrition labels will help you be more mindful of the amount of sugar you’re eating.  But  I think we need to look at all the ways extra calories are making their way into our day.  Keeping treats a treat — and not an every meal occasion — will help.  Moderation, not elimination is my motto.

WHO’s new guidelines have been published online and the agency is inviting the public to comment via its website until the end of March.

image courtesy of stephanym.rodriguez1 on flickr

Enjoy this?

share it



  • Great post!

  • Amy Cooper

    Sugar is addicting and when over consumed it is toxic to our system. It feeds cancer cells and leads to many health issues. I hear you on the blame game and agree, it’s not the cause of our problems. If is one that can be monitored and controlled with diet, awareness and policy changes. Thanks for sharing!!

  • Sugar is vulgar to our body systems. It may appear unharmful, but it affects our body, our energy, habits and is addictive.

    With all these weird carbo diets, what we should realy do in order to maintain a healthy lifestyle – decrease the amount of sugar we consume.

    Good luck and thanks for the article.

  • Momnivore

    Question: Does the recommendation of 25 grams of sugar per day include naturally occurring sugars like those in fruit? For example, one apple contains over 10 grams and same with a serving of grapes. So if I have 2 servings of fresh fruit a day – even if limiting/eliminating added sugars, I might be over the recommended level?

Copyright 2019 Nutrition Unplugged
Design by cre8d